In our most recent critical thinking class we discussed the secret to success. According to Walter Mischel that secret may be self-control. Back in the sixties, Mischel developed what has come to be known as the marshmallow test. Young children were offered a delectable single marshmallow, but told that if they held off and didn’t eat the marshmallow, fifteen minutes later they would be given two that they could then devour. Most of the children (two thirds) either ate the first marshmallow immediately or couldn’t hold out for the entire 15 minutes. One third, however, were able to delay gratification long enough to be rewarded with the second prize.
Following up with the experimental subjects years and subsequently decades later showed that there was a positive correlation of delayed gratification with a number of different outcomes such as high SAT scores, decreased incidents of substance abuse, lower body mass indices, rewarding/successful careers etc. While other researchers were focussed on using intelligence testing to predict various types of life success, Mischel was convinced that self control measured by delayed gratification was a more accurate and useful predictor.
An Article by Jonah Lehrer in The New Yorker.
While there may be a strong genetic basis for one’s ability to exercise self-control, Mischel as well as Dan Ariely, a behavioural economist, believe that it can be learned at least to a certain extent. Mischel illustrated this in later tests by giving children some tips on self distraction techniques which enabled them to hold out long enough to get the extra reward.
Dan Ariely’s take on the topic.
On a personal note, I vividly remember one report card I received in grade one. In addition to grade and effort evaluation for each subject there was also a category called Self-Control. On this particular report and specifically for Self-Control, I was given an N for Needs Improvement. I was incensed. It had only been days earlier that a siren was heard outside the classroom window and all of the students rushed to the window while I had remained at my desk continuing my important seat work. What could the teacher have been thinking… Maybe it was that thumb tack that I had put on her chair that one time.
Enjoy the links!
Fantastic blog. I can’t wait for the next instalment. !!!
Thanks Ann.
I knew you were the sneaky “tack on the seat” type!! I remember this and glad students are getting exposed to this earlier in high school. Well done Mark!
This is education at its best. Congratulations Mark. Students at Kitsilano are very fortunate to have such an opportunity. Your dedication and hard work with the implementation and development of this course have been remarkable. You deserve to be proud of what you have accomplished. Enjoy !
What a nice comment. Thanks Catherine.
Excellent work. I had the pleasure of taking your course while a student at Kistilano Secondary, and it was one of the highlights of my highschool years. I sincerely hope the model you are developing will be widely adopted in other schools; critical thinking is a profoundly important and under-emphasizeed skillset.
As is proofreading oneself before hitting ‘post’ 😉
Thanks Jason. Great to hear from you and nice recovery there.